Nimran
Habitué
- Messages
- 199
After reading discussions about some of the characters in BG3 within this forum, I decided to type my own opinions. Granted, each of my opinions comes from a limited amount of time playing with the beta before it became too big for my pc to run, but I think I still have a good idea of what the characters are about.
First off, Lae’zel is an alright character. She’s aggressive and pushy, and always tries to keep the party on track, though her preferred method for doing so is to just ignore everything and everyone else and get on with the main quest line . I wouldn’t take her if there were other options for a tank.
I love Shadowheart. I think her character is well-written, at least in the opening act. I love her secretive and distrustful nature, and the fact that if you respect her boundaries she’ll work well with you. I love that she asks you questions as much as you ask her, and that she provides insights that actually seem reasonable, rather than demented. She values subtlety and dislikes wanton destruction or pointless killing, which sounds antithetical to her status as a Shar worshipper. Speaking of which, it takes a lot of persuasiveness to get her to admit to her affiliations, and when she does she betrays a hint of disillusionment with her beliefs that seems very realistic, like she feels the same doubts that often come with religion in the real world. She’s also very useful as a cleric, which makes her my favorite of all the BG3 characters I’ve seen so far.
Astarion is… a vampire. I don’t really care for vampires much, and Astarion is no different. His personality is grating to me, if I’m honest, and I usually ended up leaving him at camp unless I really needed a hard lock picked or trap disarmed.
Gale is annoying, not because of his character, but because of his condition. If it wasn’t for that, he would be one of my favorite companions, though. He has a good sense of humor, and, like Shadowheart, prefers a diplomatic solution to a violent one.
I don’t have a lot of experience with Wyll, since I played as a warlock myself, and thus I didn’t need him, but he seems like an alright guy. You find him protecting a camp of refugees and helping to train them to defend themselves. Despite his connections, he comes across as an agreeable sort.
All in all, I’m only really impressed with one of these characters, and the others are either meh or unlikeable. I’m hoping that the good-aligned characters being added are as well done as Shadowheart. I’m not as excited for Minsc and Boo, or Jaheira, as others are, since I don’t really care for seeing old characters make a return. I’d rather just have new characters entirely, but I’m not gonna die on a hill about it.
I do wonder how deep the writers will get into the returning characters’ backgrounds, though. Part of Minsc’s charm was that he was on his dajemma at the time of the original saga, attempting to prove himself worthy to the famous Icedragon Lodge, and his epilogue ended with him being admitted into their ranks. Will the writers use that, or do they think that Minsc’s silliness is the only noteworthy aspect of him? Same with Jaheira and her Harpers questline. Will they actually give their stories the respect they deserve, or are they just using them for cheap fan service? We’ll see.
First off, Lae’zel is an alright character. She’s aggressive and pushy, and always tries to keep the party on track, though her preferred method for doing so is to just ignore everything and everyone else and get on with the main quest line . I wouldn’t take her if there were other options for a tank.
I love Shadowheart. I think her character is well-written, at least in the opening act. I love her secretive and distrustful nature, and the fact that if you respect her boundaries she’ll work well with you. I love that she asks you questions as much as you ask her, and that she provides insights that actually seem reasonable, rather than demented. She values subtlety and dislikes wanton destruction or pointless killing, which sounds antithetical to her status as a Shar worshipper. Speaking of which, it takes a lot of persuasiveness to get her to admit to her affiliations, and when she does she betrays a hint of disillusionment with her beliefs that seems very realistic, like she feels the same doubts that often come with religion in the real world. She’s also very useful as a cleric, which makes her my favorite of all the BG3 characters I’ve seen so far.
Astarion is… a vampire. I don’t really care for vampires much, and Astarion is no different. His personality is grating to me, if I’m honest, and I usually ended up leaving him at camp unless I really needed a hard lock picked or trap disarmed.
Gale is annoying, not because of his character, but because of his condition. If it wasn’t for that, he would be one of my favorite companions, though. He has a good sense of humor, and, like Shadowheart, prefers a diplomatic solution to a violent one.
I don’t have a lot of experience with Wyll, since I played as a warlock myself, and thus I didn’t need him, but he seems like an alright guy. You find him protecting a camp of refugees and helping to train them to defend themselves. Despite his connections, he comes across as an agreeable sort.
All in all, I’m only really impressed with one of these characters, and the others are either meh or unlikeable. I’m hoping that the good-aligned characters being added are as well done as Shadowheart. I’m not as excited for Minsc and Boo, or Jaheira, as others are, since I don’t really care for seeing old characters make a return. I’d rather just have new characters entirely, but I’m not gonna die on a hill about it.
I do wonder how deep the writers will get into the returning characters’ backgrounds, though. Part of Minsc’s charm was that he was on his dajemma at the time of the original saga, attempting to prove himself worthy to the famous Icedragon Lodge, and his epilogue ended with him being admitted into their ranks. Will the writers use that, or do they think that Minsc’s silliness is the only noteworthy aspect of him? Same with Jaheira and her Harpers questline. Will they actually give their stories the respect they deserve, or are they just using them for cheap fan service? We’ll see.